Photo Illustration by The Daily Beast/Getty/Drew Hoenigke

It was bitterly cold, with fresh snow and ice on the ground, when Pennsylvania State troopers arrived at Amy and Drew Hoenigke’s red-roofed home.

After making their way through a “very congested” space—the front door was blocked off by items on the porch, with large stacks of firewood lying nearby as the rural Sullivan County home’s only apparent heat source—officers were greeted by the couple in the living room.

It was Jan....

Continue Reading Their Baby Was Dying. So Why Didn’t This Couple Call 911?